Category-by-Category Comparison
Testosterone Replacement Therapy
For testosterone replacement therapy, Maximus starts at $99.99/month with three delivery options (injectable, oral enclomiphene, gel). 5 of our 8 alternatives also offer TRT. Pricing varies: DudeMeds at $77/month all-inclusive, Peter MD from $79/month on a 12-month plan, Hims at $99/month, Fridays at $129/month, and Taurus Meds from $149/month. One distinction matters before you compare those prices: the Hims plan is enclomiphene, a testosterone-support option that is not FDA-approved for this use and is not injectable TRT. Maximus unique advantage is at-home testosterone testing via LabCorp/Quest partners.
Erectile Dysfunction
For erectile dysfunction, Maximus offers Sildenafil, Tadalafil, and Vardenafil starting at $49/month, plus a compounded vardenafil + tadalafil combination the FDA has not approved or reviewed. 7 of 8 alternatives also offer ED treatment. Pricing varies significantly: Hims at $22/month, Ro at $48/month, Strut from $30/month for generics. Strut and MEDVi offer compounded 4-in-1 formulas. (Compounded drugs are not FDA-approved.) Taurus Meds has a proprietary 4-in-1 ED formula.
Key Differences Between Maximus and Its Alternatives
Understanding what separates Maximus from its competitors helps you make an informed decision. Maximus specializes in TRT with three delivery methods (injectable, oral enclomiphene, gel) and also offers ED treatment, holding a 9.2/10 rating in our provider database.
TRT Delivery Options: Maximus offers injectable, oral, and gel TRT - more options than most competitors. Hims and Ro offer TRT but with fewer delivery methods. Taurus Meds also offers multiple TRT options.
Insurance Acceptance: Maximus does not accept insurance. However, Ro accepts insurance for some services, which can significantly reduce costs. Maximus does accept HSA/FSA payments, so you can pay with pre-tax dollars.
At-Home Testing: Maximus provides at-home testosterone testing via LabCorp and Quest Diagnostics partners - a convenience not offered by all competitors.
ED Treatment: Maximus offers Sildenafil, Tadalafil, and Vardenafil individually, all FDA-approved, and a compounded vardenafil + tadalafil combination. Strut and MEDVi go further with compounded 4-in-1 formulas. No compounded formula carries FDA approval, and none has been reviewed by the FDA for safety, effectiveness, or quality.
How to Switch From Maximus to Another Provider
Switching TRT providers is straightforward but requires some planning to maintain treatment continuity.
Step 1: Request your current lab results and treatment history from Maximus before canceling.
Step 2: Choose your new provider and complete their assessment process. Most telehealth TRT providers can onboard you within 3-5 business days.
Step 3: Your new provider will likely order fresh bloodwork to establish their own baseline and verify your current treatment is appropriate.
Step 4: Cancel your Maximus subscription after confirming your new provider can fulfill your prescription without a gap in treatment.
How We Chose These Alternatives
Our ranking of Maximus alternatives is based on four key factors, weighted by their importance when you are deciding whether to switch:
Category Overlap (40% weight): We prioritize alternatives that cover both TRT and ED treatment, matching Maximus's dual-category approach.
Ratings (25% weight): Ratings shown are ManyTreatments scores based on our own research into each provider, informed by publicly available feedback. They are our editorial assessments, not third-party review-site averages.
Pricing Competitiveness (20% weight): We compare monthly costs and available discounts across providers.
Feature Set (15% weight): We evaluate consultation types, shipping speed, and additional services.
